Ok here is how it works. And I used to be involved when they would do the selecting. Coach A and Coach B are friends, Coach A says to Coach B, Hey vote for my kids and ill vote for yours. All head coaches from region get together and each coach has a list of players they nominated. all coaches vote for who they want but cannot vote for there own kids. A lot of political involvement or whos mommy cries too much or whos daddy kisses a%$. Anyone says different then they are not speaking the truth or has never been in the room when the voting was going on. Each coach has anywhere from 2 to 5 kids they want on 1st team all other kids are just roll players. When a team has a back go for 2000 yards or so and that back is all everything but only one lineman, is 1st team then something is wrong. Makes the said linemen, receiver, QB ect: not wanna play or at least put forth max effort. Now I am a big supporter of to the victor goes the spoils and Graham got the shaft bad on all region team.