Jump to content
SWVASPORTS.COM

Recommended Posts

Posted
12 minutes ago, Widespread_Panic said:

Definitely should go to Hayes. His first year on varsity they go undefeated in the Mountain District. Ethan Collins is good but in his previous three years on varsity Wise Central's record was .500 at best. 

Last year they were above .500.  They have gotten better every year Collins has played.  It's hard to accomplish as a one man show (Union).  When Hayes moved up with another freshman playing quality minutes, they are now undefeated. 

Posted
32 minutes ago, CriticalNoise said:

Who gets it? Ean Hayes

Who deserves it? Kam Bostic

who gets it? Ean Hayes and who deserves it is Ean Hayes.  Idk where Kam Bostic even came into the picture, maybe daddy revolving the whole game around him.  Ean has scored against everyone even when the whole time the central offense was centered around ethan. 

Posted

This has always been a question when it comes to these awards.  Some people think it should go to the best player on the best team.  Others think it should go to the player whose team wouldn't be where they are without them.  In this case I think Hayes is both.  IMO Central would not have gone undefeated through the district without him.  

Posted

I don't have a dog in this fight, but I would give it to Hayes as well.  I think Bostic is probably the number 2.  I have watched 5-6 Central games, and Collins doesn't impress me at all.  No matter what people think about his dad, he's a great player.  He really has nobody to help him other than Bunch (who I think played kind of lost this season).  If anything, I think Bostic tries too hard to involve the football players in the offense which costs the team scoring opportunities.  

Posted
3 hours ago, Elder statesman said:

I don't have a dog in this fight, but I would give it to Hayes as well.  I think Bostic is probably the number 2.  I have watched 5-6 Central games, and Collins doesn't impress me at all.  No matter what people think about his dad, he's a great player.  He really has nobody to help him other than Bunch (who I think played kind of lost this season).  If anything, I think Bostic tries too hard to involve the football players in the offense which costs the team scoring opportunities.  

Collins is a very good player but he has also benefited from playing in a weak district.  

Posted

Like I said earlier in the year, Hayes is the best player in southwest Va.  He is ahead of where Mac Mc Clung was as a freshman ! If he just concentrates on just basketball , stays off the football field and injury possibility , he will be a for sure D1 prospect ! When Boggs put him on Bostic, he shut him down ! I don’t think there is anyone in area that can stop him, jumps out of the gym, quick as a cat, and shooting range out there ! Focus on basketball Ian, gonna be enjoyable 3 more years to watch !

Posted
22 hours ago, Observer said:

Collins is a very good player but he has also benefited from playing in a weak district.  

Doesn't Bostic play in the same distric as Collins? Hayes, Collins and Bostic are all good players, just think Hayes is better.

Posted
6 hours ago, honestjohn said:

Doesn't Bostic play in the same distric as Collins? Hayes, Collins and Bostic are all good players, just think Hayes is better.

I wasn’t saying that I think Bostic is better than Collins

Posted
6 hours ago, honestjohn said:

Doesn't Bostic play in the same distric as Collins? Hayes, Collins and Bostic are all good players, just think Hayes is better.

He is.  I’m BSG thru and thru and I loathe anything Central, esp in boys sports, but trying to argue Kam, who’s a very good player, is a better player than Hayes is being disingenuous. 

Posted

I have no horse in this race but I have watched Central vs Virginia High this year and Collins posted a triple double. In my years watching high school basketball in this area, triple doubles are pretty rare, especially against a team like Virginia high. Hayes, Collins, Bostic have all played the same competition this year in the same district so how does that have any impact on the decision. If I am not mistaken, Collins recently just became Central's All time scoring leader passing mcamis. I am not understanding how he could not be worthy of winning district poy. Hayes is a great player, Central went undefeated in their district play, it has to either be collins or hayes, and I would give it to the senior over the freshman

Posted

I think if things are basically equal (and I don’t know if they are just speaking in generalities), I would defer to Senior for POY. Also, in the grand scheme of things, these awards don’t mean much. 

Posted

I am biased because I am a Lee guy but I personally think Pendergraft should be in the conversation. Now I do think that Hayes should be the winner but I also think Pendergraft does not get much credit. According to the BHC he is averaging the most points a game with 22 I believe and 7 rebounds per game and also 3 or 4 assists. He stepped up big against union and gate City when they beat them at home. Earlier in the year when they beat abingdon at home they were down going into the fourth quarter and he had 17 in the 4th and finished with 30. He is also the all time leading scorer for boys at Lee. I know their record is not great but the kid should definitely be in the mix. I think they will likely give it to Collins but like I said Hayes should probably be the winner.

Posted
5 minutes ago, VFL62 said:

I am biased because I am a Lee guy but I personally think Pendergraft should be in the conversation. Now I do think that Hayes should be the winner but I also think Pendergraft does not get much credit. According to the BHC he is averaging the most points a game with 22 I believe and 7 rebounds per game and also 3 or 4 assists. He stepped up big against union and gate City when they beat them at home. Earlier in the year when they beat abingdon at home they were down going into the fourth quarter and he had 17 in the 4th and finished with 30. He is also the all time leading scorer for boys at Lee. I know their record is not great but the kid should definitely be in the mix. I think they will likely give it to Collins but like I said Hayes should probably be the winner.

Pendergraft is definitely a great player.  If you take him off that team they definitely struggle to get wins.  Unfortunately you don't see too many POY from the 4th place team.  

Posted
2 hours ago, Observer said:

Pendergraft is definitely a great player.  If you take him off that team they definitely struggle to get wins.  Unfortunately you don't see too many POY from the 4th place team.  

Yea oftentimes if you put those types of guys on an actual good team they would look like role players. Dishman from Castlewood last year led all swva players with almost 30 ppg and was definitely not the most impressive player in our area. Solid players on bad teams look far better than they actually are

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...