Stelley Posted June 14 Report Posted June 14 Bit of a head scratcher but how in the world can clay be Cumberland District POTY but 1D POTY is Hamilton???? Both are good players but you have to be district player of the year to be the region???? Only exception is if you’re in a district with teams in different classes. Only way this is possible is your dad being the coach more than likely. Hogo POTY is likely Tuell M7 POTY is likely Humphreys SWD POTY is Whitt from V High. Pretty big snub IMO. V High finished 3rd in the district. SWD teams continue to hate Lebanon. 2D POTY is definitely Gobble Quote
1inStripes Posted June 16 Report Posted June 16 Clay isn't the son of Coach Chris Clay. Chris only has daughters. Quote
Stelley Posted June 16 Author Report Posted June 16 29 minutes ago, 1inStripes said: Clay isn't the son of Coach Chris Clay. Chris only has daughters. I think his dad is on the staff. Still his uncle Quote
ehcwasp Posted June 18 Report Posted June 18 On 6/14/2025 at 2:23 PM, Stelley said: Bit of a head scratcher but how in the world can clay be Cumberland District POTY but 1D POTY is Hamilton???? Both are good players but you have to be district player of the year to be the region???? Only exception is if you’re in a district with teams in different classes. Only way this is possible is your dad being the coach more than likely. Hogo POTY is likely Tuell M7 POTY is likely Humphreys SWD POTY is Whitt from V High. Pretty big snub IMO. V High finished 3rd in the district. SWD teams continue to hate Lebanon. 2D POTY is definitely Gobble You dont have to be a district POY to be a region POY, just have to be a first teamer. But I would agree that it is unusual. From reading the Bristol paper, seems more likely that region POY was based on the performance in the region tournament, because Hamilton dominated in all 3 games Quote
Stelley Posted June 18 Author Report Posted June 18 11 hours ago, ehcwasp said: You dont have to be a district POY to be a region POY, just have to be a first teamer. But I would agree that it is unusual. From reading the Bristol paper, seems more likely that region POY was based on the performance in the region tournament, because Hamilton dominated in all 3 games Prior years yes you do. There are only 4 candidates to be state poty, and they are the 4 region poty. Only exceptions to be region poty and not district is if you are in a district with teams that are different classifications like the M7. 1inStripes 1 Quote
Stelley Posted June 24 Author Report Posted June 24 Class 2 and 3 Players of the year both come from the M7. One of the better baseball districts in the state from top to bottom. Quote
BigWinners Posted June 26 Report Posted June 26 On 6/24/2025 at 6:03 PM, Stelley said: Class 2 and 3 Players of the year both come from the M7. One of the better baseball districts in the state from top to bottom. Where can we see the 2A and 3A full lists? Quote
Stelley Posted June 26 Author Report Posted June 26 8 hours ago, BigWinners said: Where can we see the 2A and 3A full lists? 2A full list hasn’t been posted, have seen posts from battle saying Porter got it. Heres 3A BigWinners 1 Quote
BigWinners Posted July 7 Report Posted July 7 A Wise kid makes it but not one Union kid 😕. Not Skeen not Neff not Chandler it’s silly. Quote
Stelley Posted July 7 Author Report Posted July 7 1 hour ago, BigWinners said: A Wise kid makes it but not one Union kid 😕. Not Skeen not Neff not Chandler it’s silly. What is silly is the Kennedy was first team catcher M7 but in region chandler was first team. Skeen didn’t even make the all region list. Now yes I’ll agree Wyatt and foster both had a good year especially to be underclassmen but I don’t think I’ve ever seen two underclassmen make the all state team that didn’t make it out of the first round of region. Think it’s a gobble-foster I’ll scratch your back you scratch mine scenario. BigWinners 1 Quote
BigWinners Posted Monday at 04:37 AM Report Posted Monday at 04:37 AM On 7/7/2025 at 7:22 PM, Stelley said: What is silly is the Kennedy was first team catcher M7 but in region chandler was first team. Skeen didn’t even make the all region list. Now yes I’ll agree Wyatt and foster both had a good year especially to be underclassmen but I don’t think I’ve ever seen two underclassmen make the all state team that didn’t make it out of the first round of region. Think it’s a gobble-foster I’ll scratch your back you scratch mine scenario. Nailed it 100% Quote
Smitty Posted Monday at 12:31 PM Report Posted Monday at 12:31 PM Maybe it’s time we all agree that the all district-region-state is not a real honor system to accurately rate players. What it actually is, is behind the door deal making between coaches that does not truly give accolades to many deserving players. Stelley, Tigerman10 and EH31 2 1 Quote
swvavol Posted Monday at 01:23 PM Report Posted Monday at 01:23 PM 51 minutes ago, Smitty said: Maybe it’s time we all agree that the all district-region-state is not a real honor system to accurately rate players. What it actually is, is behind the door deal making between coaches that does not truly give accolades to many deserving players. This is 100% accurate Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.