They also call them, "state champions". The VHSL didn't make them forfeit because common sense was used. There are concrete rules that must be followed, but concrete thinking in the face of common sense shouldn't always be the case. What I am getting at is........1/8th of a difference would not have made a difference in the way Richlands dominated the game after the first quarter, and the VHSL knew that. Additionally, one must realize that if Richlands were to win that game (and they did) there was going to be an excuse REGARDLESS of whether there were cleats involved and that's exactly happened. Before Richlands was found out regarding the cleats, the talks of "a needed investigation" into the Richlands fire department and watering down the field was already the first thing to come out of Salem. It would NOT have ended whether cleats were involved or not. There was going to be an excuse if Salem lost. Now certainly, the clear-cut cheating made the scandal bigger and it should have, but you can better believe, there was going to be a scandal regardless, if Salem were to lose that game.
Final example, Salem went to Lee High a few years earlier and lost in the state semi's. They petitioned the VHSL to investigate Lee High into "muddying up" their field. If Salem would have traveled to Amherst or Blacksburg and lost, it would have been chalked up as a loss and nothing more, but when losing in far SWVA, they simply couldn't stand it, and yes, there was exactly that, an excuse made for the loss. With all of this written, that no way justifies what Richlands did. That was a boneheaded move, but I don't call every player on Richlands team from 92 a cheater. They had no clue about another 8th of an inch being in violation of cleats. I call them players, state champions. I was at that game and Richlands was clearly better.
P.S. A little know fact many forget about is what the VHSL did to Richlands the next season. Richlands was banned from the playoffs. The 93 team in my opinion was equally as good as the 92 team by seasons end. They were 7-3, but all three losses were close and nail bitingly close. By season's end, that team was rolling. Richlands in fact, did receive punishment for their actions, and many fail to bring up the 1993 team and what may have been when discussing the cleats scandal. If that 93 team could have made the playoffs, they could have made some noise and been trouble. They dramatically improved from game 1 through 10.