Richmond, VA, is like Charlotte, NC. It's called open enrollment. This means, if you live within the Richmond/Charlotte City limits, you can go to any school you choose as long as you get yourself to the school. The cities have school boundaries, and JM has its own boundary, but if you live outside of that boundary, but still in Richmond, and you want to go to John Marshall, you can go as long as you provide your own transportation. Open enrollment is done because of parents that work around the city and they work perhaps in an area Other than the district they live in, so they can drop their kids off while going to work. This ie one reason for open enrollment. Academic reasons are another. If a parent is unhappy with the academics of the local school boundary and they want their kid to go to the top school in Charlotte or Richmond, they can send them there as long as they take them. One of the goals is to increase competitveness academically for all schools within the city.
The problem or downside. When 1 school has an AAU, NFL, or major Div 1 connection on the coaching staff. The best athletes will often flock to this certain school, and the danger with a large city is......there are a LOT of kids to choose from. How does it work in Charlotte and other cities like this around the country. It's like Waccamole with success. One school has the coaching connection and gets the kids and dominates, then the coach leaves and that school falls off and another school rises to the top and takes the reigns, then that coach leaves and another school comes to the forefront. We've seen it in Charlotte over the years and how it rotates with first Independence, then Butler, onto Providence, onto Catholic, etc, etc. The coach at John Marshall will not be there in 3 years. He will be in the college ranks and you will see Marshall slowly fall off, and somebody else in Richmond will gain a coaching/AAU connection and they will rise up.
John Marshall is within the rules. Their coach is doing his job and doing a good job. If folks are upset with it again.....blame Richmond or the VHSL. John Marshall and their staff are doing what any other staff would do, if in the same situation.